Many of these gain structure difficulties are solved with digital audio. In most recent DAWs, the noise floor is no longer an issue since system noise is so low that it has no effect on the signal at all.
Also, headroom isn’t an issue. But it’s still important!
We have an ultimate limit in digital (0dBFS, or decibels Full Scale). Any signal that is higher than that will be clipped. However, until that point, digital is a fully linear medium; thus, there is no gradual onset of compression and distortion like there is with traditional recording.
Great. So, why should you care about gaining staging if digital recording appears to have solved all of the problems?
The main reason for this is that every digital chain has at least one (and sometimes two) physical stages (hint: it’s the A in your AD and DA converters).
Your signal must pass through an original stage before being converted to digital when you record. On the way out to your monitors, it must also be converted back to analogue.
These analogue stages suffer from the same gain structure issues as the digital stages:
You’ll be fighting the noise floor if you record too low.
When you record at too high a volume, you risk distortion and clipping.
As a result, when recording, it’s best to keep your levels low. As a general rule, equate -18dBFS to the analogue norm of 0dBVU.
If your peaks aren’t much higher than -10dBFS and your average level is around -18dBFS, you’ll have a signal that’s probably perfect.
Keep in mind that more dynamic instruments, such as drums or percussion, may require more space due to their huge peaks.
When your songs are recorded, the need for effective gain staging does not go away…
Examine all of your plugins, even though you’re in the digital realm. How many are based on old analogue hardware such as compressors, EQs, console channels, tape machines, and so on?
Most of them would display the same “non-linear” behaviour as their standard counterparts if the modelling were done correctly. As a result, the same rules apply: the more you push them, the more they compress, saturate, and distort.
This isn’t usually a negative trait. It can be used for tone shaping in a unique way. However, if you use high levels in all of your plugins, your mix may sound brittle, harsh, and multiple.
So your best bet is to stick to the same approach of optimal gain staging that you used when recording: Aim for a level of -18dBFS as an average.
Maintaining proper gain structure throughout your mix will be easier if you keep it conservative.
If you have done everything correctly, your master bus levels should be low enough that clipping won’t be an issue.
As a result, offer headroom and gain staging the care they require. And now you can get on with mixing without worrying about your faders!